I lucked out at Goodwill today. I was looking around, trying to find something useful or interesting, and came upon the toy section, and lo and behold, loose Monster High Dolls. There was first edition Frankie, Draculaura, and Lagoona, Gil, a Clawdeen I couldn't identify (purple streaks in hair, but not S1600), and a DOTD Cleo with DOTD Clawdeen's dress, and 1st Ghoulia's boots.

But I didn't buy any of these.
I bought these:
http://i1116.photobucket.com/albums/.../DSC018481.jpg

Holt was 4.29, and is missing his shirt. DOTD Lagoona was 3.99, and yes, I know, she's a hot mess. All the girl dolls were. DOTD Deuce, because he's missing his left forearm, was a whoppin 1.29.

Wanted to get another boy CAM anyhow, now I have another reason to do so.
I am a little annoyed though. The Goodwill employees, to prevent the shoes from being stolen, wrapped the legs of the dolls with packing tape - all the way up the leg! There was no way to avoid removing some of the silver striping off of Deuce's pants taking it off.

All they had to do was wrap up the shoe and the lower portion of the leg. Yikes.
Irregardless, I'm surprised and happy I was able to find these dolls in any condition.