HBO's A Song of Ice and Fire: A Game of Thrones

**Patreek** · April 1, 2011, 01:04am

I'm surprised there hasn't been any talk on here of this show yet. Seems right up the ally of fans here.

This new HBO series starts in a few weeks. It is an adaptation of George R R Martins AMAZING books. I'm SO excited!!

BEHOLD!

The Game Begins

**BCreviews4628** · April 1, 2011, 07:53am

Both this and Camelot look good to me, but since they are on HBO & Starz, most likely they will be full of pointless nude & sex scenes, just because they can do it.

**Mr. Shokoti** · April 1, 2011, 09:48am

Originally Posted by BCreviews4628

Both this and Camelot look good to me, but since they are on HBO & Starz, most likely they will be full of pointless nude & sex scenes, just because they can do it.

I'm happy I'm not the only one who thinks that. Look, I have no problem with porn, but I hate when HBO tries to get as close as they can to it in a show that isn't about sex. I still watch True Blood, but I really get sick of the explicit sex scenes. It just takes me right out of the story. There's a time & place for everything.

Originally Posted by Patreek

This new HBO series starts in a few weeks. It is an adaptation of George R R Martins AMAZING books. I'm SO excited!!

I've heard about it but have never read the books. Is it fantasy or just a semi-realistic medieval drama?

**Patreek** · April 1, 2011, 03:50pm

Originally Posted by BCreviews4628

Both this and Camelot look good to me, but since they are on HBO & Starz, most likely they will be full of pointless nude & sex scenes, just because they can do it.

Totally get what you are saying and most times would agree. In this instance though the source material is full of that kinda stuff and the show likely will cut a lot out. One article i read recently said it was like a modern lotr accept people get horny. Lol

Originally Posted by Mr. Shokoti

I'm happy I'm not the only one who thinks that. Look, I have no problem with porn, but I hate when HBO tries to get as close as they can to it in a show that isn't about sex. I still watch True Blood, but I really get sick of the explicit sex scenes. It just takes me right out of the story. There's a time & place for everything.

I've heard about it but have never read the books. Is it fantasy or just a semi-realistic medieval drama?

Its sorta both. Its definitely fantasy but its written like its historical fiction. Very realistic and gritty and the crazy fantasy moments are more spread out. Because of this when they happen they have a.much larger impact. Its def a magical fantasy world they are living in tho.

**gbagok** · April 1, 2011, 04:09pm

I agree about the gratuitous nature of the sex and violence, but this looks pretty awesome--particularly the costumes. I don't know the books, are these historical fiction or is it fantasy? It's kind of hard to tell so I'll have to look them up.

**Ivan** · April 1, 2011, 04:57pm

This looks pretty interesting, but since I don't have HBO it means I'll have to wait another year for it to come out on Bluray...

Originally Posted by BCreviews4628

Both this and Camelot look good to me, but since they are on HBO & Starz, most likely they will be full of pointless nude & sex scenes, just because they can do it.

I kinda make a difference between HBO and Starz in that respect. I would expect Camelot to be more vulgar and blunt. I didn't watch the third season of True Blood yet, but I didn't mind the sex scenes in the first two seasons. I actually thought they were very well done. But then again, I'm European...

**BCreviews4628** · April 1, 2011, 05:16pm

otally get what you are saying and most times would agree. In this instance though the source material is full of that kinda stuff and the show likely will cut a lot out. One article i read recently said it was like a modern lotr accept people get horny. Lol

Oooh ok, I never read the books, but if that stuff is there, it's kinda diffrent. I guess I sound like a prude lol, but like Mr. Shokoti said, it takes me out of the story.

Haha, lotr, accept people get horny, gotta love that quote! Cool seeing Sean Bean kinda decked out like Borimir again.

**Brad2dbone** · April 1, 2011, 05:46pm

I'm so excited for this show that I'm going to order HBO, rather than wait to Netflix the DVD's. What's more, the 5th book finally has an official release date.

As far as the nudey stuff goes, the book does have it's fair share of sex and nudity, so the show will likely depict all of that.

**Ivan** · April 1, 2011, 05:56pm

BTW, there is a really cool iPad app out there - Ice and Fire. It's basically a weather app, but it displays weather using footage from the show where such weather occurs. Pretty cool, kinda like Weather HD only with Game of Thrones theme

**Patreek** · April 2, 2011, 06:41pm

Originally Posted by gbagok

I agree about the gratuitous nature of the sex and violence, but this looks pretty awesome--particularly the costumes. I don't know the books, are these historical fiction or is it fantasy? It's kind of hard to tell so I'll have to look them up.

Fantasy but much more realistic than most fantasy. Reads like historical fiction.and then boom something crazy happens lol its great stuff!!!

edit:

So yesterday here in NYC (well all week long actually but i went yesterday) they had a promotional food truck where all the food served was from the Song of Ice and Fire books/hbo show. I went and had HEAD CHEESE! Which I never thought i'd have in my life... its pigs brain. It was really good, prepared by a famous chef and free?! Best promo ever!

**Mr. Shokoti** · April 2, 2011, 08:03pm

Originally Posted by Patreek

I went and had HEAD CHEESE! Which I never thought i'd have in my life... its pigs brain. It was really good, prepared by a famous chef and free?! Best promo ever!

Yechhh! Everytime I hear about headcheese, I think of The Texas Chainsaw Massacre.

**Patreek** · April 5, 2011, 01:31am

Here are pictures from the event.. .including the brains i ate. mmm nom nom nom

**Mr. Shokoti** · April 5, 2011, 01:59am

Dang! I refuse to eat tomatoes & green beans. I can't even imagine brains. I'd make an awful zombie.

**13977** · April 5, 2011, 04:14am

I was going to start a thread on this soon, really looking forward to it.

**Ivan** · April 5, 2011, 01:22pm

There's an almost 15-minute preview available on HBO website and also on iTunes. Its in the form of a podcast, just search for "Game of Thrones". If you can't wait, this will help you a bit (or maybe just make it worse

)

**Brad2dbone** · April 5, 2011, 01:49pm

I watched the preview and it gave me high hopes for the show. It's obviously not going to be an exact adaptation, but it looks like it will be very faithful. One question though: where was Theon?

**Mr. Shokoti** · April 5, 2011, 02:13pm

I had figured with the obsession that this series of books seems to bring out, the series must have started in the late 70's or early 80's. I was surprised to find out last night that it is only 15 years old.

**Patreek** · April 5, 2011, 06:36pm

Originally Posted by Mr. Shokoti

Dang! I refuse to eat tomatoes & green beans. I can't even imagine brains. I'd make an awful zombie.

I know right? I still can't believe I ate it. lol The things I do in the name of Geekdom

Originally Posted by 13977

I was going to start a thread on this soon, really looking forward to it.

Yea its going to be great. Have you read the books? I'm really excited that a new one is coming out in July!

Originally Posted by Ivan

There's an almost 15-minute preview available on HBO website and also on iTunes. Its in the form of a podcast, just search for "Game of Thrones". If you can't wait, this will help you a bit (or maybe just make it worse

)

I've been going back and forth on whether I want to watch the preview and spoil it or wait for the premier. I"m SOO curious though... eeeeee

Originally Posted by Brad2dbone

I watched the preview and it gave me high hopes for the show. It's obviously not going to be an exact adaptation, but it looks like it will be very faithful. One question though: where was Theon?

I'm so glad! I get so nervous with things like this. Obviously as you said it won't be an exact adaptation but I still hope it is faithful and doesn't ruin it as so often happens with fantasy adaptations. Glad to hear you liked the preview though. Theon Best be in there... hm.... maybe its too early to have seen him? Has there been a casting announcment on him?

Originally Posted by Mr. Shokoti

I had figured with the obsession that this series of books seems to bring out, the series must have started in the late 70's or early 80's. I was surprised to find out last night that it is only 15 years old.

Yea its pretty current, a new book in the series comes out in July.. with 2 or 3 more after that.

**gbagok** · April 5, 2011, 08:10pm

Okay, so the show made it clear they like beheadings in those first 15 minutes!

I wonder if that prominent guy really died off screen in the beginning or if he'll show up again later in the series. Can't wait to see the rest of it on DVD in a year for $120.00.

**13977** · April 6, 2011, 04:19am

Originally Posted by Patreek

Yea its going to be great. Have you read the books? I'm really excited that a new one is coming out in July!

No I've not read the books, maybe I should check them out if I like the series but I've already got so many books on my 'to read' shelf.

**Brad2dbone** · April 6, 2011, 05:37am

Originally Posted by Patreek

I'm so glad! I get so nervous with things like this. Obviously as you said it won't be an exact adaptation but I still hope it is faithful and doesn't ruin it as so often happens with fantasy adaptations. Glad to hear you liked the preview though. Theon Best be in there... hm.... maybe its too early to have seen him? Has there been a casting announcment on him?

Minor spoilers ahead for those who didn't watch the preview...

Yeah, they predictably decided to ditch focusing on the POV character and bounced around a little more instead, and the things that were different made sense, because there's no narrator and there isn't time to explain everything through dialogue, so things were changed to give us visual cues instead, such as a brief scene where Septa Mordane is praising Sansa's stitches while Arya looks forlorn, and then cut to Bran failing at archery and then Arya nails a bulls-eye. In only a minute or so, we learn a lot about Arya's character by showing her do something that didn't happen in the book (nailing the bulls-eye).

The part that was missing Theon was when Ned lops off the deserter's head, it didn't show Theon kick it like in the book. IDK what that's about, but I guess we'll find out. Theon has been cast though, he's being played by a dude named Alfie Allen.

**Patreek** · April 17, 2011, 04:50pm

Originally Posted by 13977

No I've not read the books, maybe I should check them out if I like the series but I've already got so many books on my 'to read' shelf.

Yes definitely put them on your list. They are like crack on paper. Honestly I am not a huge "reader" but these books drew me in like none other have. Also I've noticed that people from all.walks of lofe that I know seem to really enjoy them which is odd for a book like this. Male female young old

Originally Posted by Brad2dbone

Minor spoilers ahead for those who didn't watch the preview...

Yeah, they predictably decided to ditch focusing on the POV character and bounced around a little more instead, and the things that were different made sense, because there's no narrator and there isn't time to explain everything through dialogue, so things were changed to give us visual cues instead, such as a brief scene where Septa Mordane is praising Sansa's stitches while Arya looks forlorn, and then cut to Bran failing at archery and then Arya nails a bulls-eye. In only a minute or so, we learn a lot about Arya's character by showing her do something that didn't happen in the book (nailing the bulls-eye).

The part that was missing Theon was when Ned lops off the deserter's head, it didn't show Theon kick it like in the book. IDK what that's about, but I guess we'll find out. Theon has been cast though, he's being played by a dude named Alfie Allen.

Very interesting. That does seem like an odd thing to leave out..hmmm

**edit**

OK SO THE PREMIERE IS TONIGHT!! SOO excited!! So who is all watching! I'm going to a premiere party here in nyc with a bunch of other nerds. Free jello shots every time someone dies!

**Brad2dbone** · April 18, 2011, 02:07pm

I waited until the last minute to order HBO, and unfortunately wasn't able to order it in time, so I missed the premier.It's OK though, I ordered it today and will be able to catch one of the many repeats, so I'll be watching it tonight!

**Mr. Shokoti** · April 18, 2011, 02:22pm

Originally Posted by Brad2dbone

I waited until the last minute to order HBO, and unfortunately wasn't able to order it in time, so I missed the premier.It's OK though, I ordered it today and will be able to catch one of the many repeats, so I'll be watching it tonight!

If you have On Demand with your cable service, just watch that. The only reason True Blood & Dexter are the only current TV shows I'm caught up on is thanks to On Demand.

**Piccolo Daimaoh** · April 18, 2011, 03:22pm

Not a bad premier. I'm hooked. I thought Sean Bean was great.

Thread: HBO's A Song of Ice and Fire: A Game of Thrones

Thread Tools

Search Thread

Display

HBO's A Song of Ice and Fire: A Game of Thrones

Posting Permissions