If You Could Pick Only One Source For MOTUC, What Would It Be?

[shadowfall1976]

Yes! Filmation is leading the pack!!

Without a doubt, Filmation is the most recognized and iconic version of MOTU....

And why not? It only helped catapult MOTU into every home in America that had a TV, as well as whatever countries had access to it. I guess the loud Minority have said their piece....Filmation is at this moment even ahead of the Vintage toyline 33 to 28....and almost tied....as it should be they both go hand in hand....

She-Ra only happened because of Filmation....200X used Filmation as a base....Filmation created Adam's story.

[sirsniffy]

Filmation without a doubt for me.

[Lich Leech]

I went for 2002 cartoon, the best remix of MOTU in my opinion. I might have voted for the MVC comics, but as I haven't read them, I'am unsure of how good they are.

2002 was miles better than Filmation, IMHO. My only quibble was some of the stylistic choices, ie the appearance of Castle Grayskull, Skeletor's vampire teeth, He-Man's asterisk armor, etc.

[Sky Breaker]

Where does this desire come from for their to be only one source? MOTU like every other toy based property has seen cartoons and various media, it been handled by various writers and has seen many incarnations. There is no definitive Transformers, Spider-Man, Batman or any other fictional franchise for that matter.

Spider-Man was introduced with high tech web shooters, and then re-imagined with organic webbing. He's had gimmicky spider themed merchandise, movies, television and some pretty Amazing friends along the way. He has existed in 2099, and has been drawn as a nerdy Milhouse, a muscled sex symbol, and even as a different race. Otherwise he would cease to exist.

Every version of MOTU contributes to the lore and characters in its own way, although some versions seem to outweigh others in the matter of just how much we care to acknowledge. These merchandise driven brands would not survive if they weren't rehashed, and irregardless of how many different versions of the story their are, people still pick and choose what they want to explain the inconsistencies.

[bcrduke]

I chose Filmation because it allows, in MOTUC anyway, for characters from vintage MOTU, vintage pop, and then some.

[Uki]

I'm cheating and voting "Other." My good buddy Scooter has some wicked "fan-fiction" that encompasses ALL of these and more!

[Piccolo Daimaoh]

Where does this desire come from for their to be only one source? MOTU like every other toy based property has seen cartoons and various media, it been handled by various writers and has seen many incarnations. There is no definitive Transformers, Spider-Man, Batman or any other fictional franchise for that matter.

Spider-Man was introduced with high tech web shooters, and then re-imagined with organic webbing. He's had gimmicky spider themed merchandise, movies, television and some pretty Amazing friends along the way. He has existed in 2099, and has been drawn as a nerdy Milhouse, a muscled sex symbol, and even as a different race. Otherwise he would cease to exist.

Every version of MOTU contributes to the lore and characters in its own way, although some versions seem to outweigh others in the matter of just how much we care to acknowledge. These merchandise driven brands would not survive if they weren't rehashed, and irregardless of how many different versions of the story their are, people still pick and choose what they want to explain the inconsistencies.

Here, here! Probably the best way to sum up how the successful lines stay relevant. You have said it all.

[Nemisythe]

Vintage Toyline!!!

As much as I liked the 4 early mini comics, I did like the addition of technology into the stories and additions of characters with the newer minis and the fact that they didn't really explain too much or feel obligated to explain everything! Sometimes we forget what makes some things special to us because we begin to demand logistic explanations for things to feel like it can be real to some extent. Me I like the fantasy, mystery and the unexplained... it is what is; a universe of sword, sorcery science and magic with unique characters.

I do appreciate the various forms and even when they attempted to bridge and expand on things in a more grown up level. But I really favour the Vintage Toyline!

[MLHumble]

I chose early mini comics as that's what I like best, but I think motuc with only one source would be very boring indeed.

I agree. I love the MYP treatment personally, but I love 'em all. The more sources the merrier. If only one, what would we have to talk about?

[Collec-Tor]

With only one choice, I've gotta go with the early comics! Simple, serious with some humor (look for it, it's there), a real threat of SPELLED OUT DEATH for He-Man on almost every page from that CREEPY Alcala Skeletor - I enjoyed the cartoon (mostly for Teela's one-piece bikini...), but I straight up LOVED the first two series of mini-comics. They set my expectation for how gritty the world of Eternia REALLY is... kind of like real life...

[He-Dad]

Filmation....easy choice. (Vintage a close second as there are some important characters ie. Rio Blast and Scareglow, that weren't in the cartoon)

[Berserker79]

The best of the best, of course: The vintage line!

[H.A.L.9000]

Vintage...or the mini comics...

[uaxuctum]

I would pick Filmation, without the slightest shred of doubt.