I think part of the problem is that there are so many gray areas when it comes to why certain decisions were made because we're not privy to all of the factors that influenced those decisions. Throw a passionate fanbase on top of that, and you get a lot of finger pointing in all directions. Also, most fans probably don't fall into one camp consistently. I can be a Matty appologist today and rip them a new one tomorrow. It depends on what mood I'm in and whether or not my buttons have been pushed by a Matty announcment or even other fans.