All of the cards look to be in excellent/case fresh shape and are all unpunched. The first auction I saw was He-Man and right away the card looked like a repro to me. The reds and blues are way too dark and over saturated looking. The other MOC figures look the same. What do you guys think?
Here's the answer to your question: what is the likelihood that he has a Trapjaw AND Tri-Klops both on a NEW card WITH a clear bubble? Compare all of his "carded" figures to his Evil-Lyn (which is real).
On the upside, he's correct in saying that all the figures are 100% real.