How would you rank the Female figures in the line?

[shadowfall1976]

Just curious with 16 females in the line, and not everyone collects them, or some only collect the girls....
how everyone would rank them, according to how well they are done, and which their favorites are.

I would do one for the guys, but honestly, there are so many of them, I wouldn't be able to keep track
of them all....plus it seems like the girls get the least love in the line outside a few more popular ones.
So I thought I'd send some their way, and I never realized there was only 16 of them, out of the whole
line, and granted POP makes up the majority of them anyway, and God knows we hardly have any POP....

Edit:
You don't have to own them to rank them, please rank all of them....I don't own Goddess, Marlena, BG Teela, Catra (yet), or the Star Sisters but I ranked them accordingly.

And I didn't count TOD Sorceress, because while she may be a convention exclusive, her time on Matty has not passed yet, so she is not available to everyone yet, even though a few online stores had her, but it was her convention stock, so I do not, and did not count her. Technically she is not available to everyone outside convention release until next month.

Each She-Ra has to be counted separate
Edit.....

There are only 16 previously released Classics girls to choose from....rank them in order from favorite to least favorite....

Teela
Goddess
Adora
Evil-Lyn
She-Ra
Catra
BG Teela
Marlena
BP She-Ra
BG Evil-Lyn
Starla
Jewelstar
Tallstar
Sorceress
Shadow Weaver
Frosta

Hera is my ranking....

1) Frosta (I know she's not as white as she should be, and she has a few other minor flaws....minor to me, but I love her overall sculpt, despite the flaws)
2) Teela
3) Sorceress (She'd be my #1, but her wing drums are hard to miss)
4) Adora
5) BP She-Ra (mostly for her ability to mix parts with 1.0, but it is her buck, so I pick her first)
6) Catra
7) She-Ra
8) Shadow Weaver
9) BG Evil-Lyn
10) Evil-Lyn
11) Starla

These I could really care less about, but, they are still ranked in order.
12) BG Teela
13) Marlena
14) Goddess
15) Tallstar
16) Jewelstar

[oulala]

1) shadow weaver. She is perfect.
2) BP She-ra. She is really good.
3) Catra - would have been number 2 if not for the gnarly left hand
4) BG Evil Lyn - best make up award. Also brand new articulated gauntlets.
5) Teela. Most beautiful Face award, but the rigid dress is a big flaw
6) Adora. Best character ever! But the outfit is too thick and the skirt is atrocious! Needs a 2.o version
7) Frosta. Pity about the hip drums showing through the dress - and all other problems. Love the
Face sculpt and sculpted booty
8) Sorceress - nice character, wings cumbersome
9)evil lyn - all right
10) BG Teela- nasty face but otherwise really fun figure
11) Starla - easily the best of the star sisters. Beautiful face and make up.
12) Tall Star - all right but not into that character. Terrible diaper looking loincloth
13) She-ra - beautiful filmation face. Horrid dress. Rigid, unsightly, looks like a man with a dress.
Very disappointing. And the head woth the big hole in the forehead was really a bad idea.
14) Marlena - horrible heads - scary eyes - terrible burrito like dress that turns her into a useless statue. Be gone!
15) Jewelstar. Piece of plastic junk. Currently at the bottom of my bottomless box of stuff.
16) goddess - i dont like the character ans never bought her that's why she is the last figure listed.

[The Hultquist]

1) Evil-Lyn - One of the two I had as a kid
2) Teela - The other one I had as a kid
3) Battleground Teela - What's not to like about a female barbarian in a gold bikini?
4) She-Ra - Really impressed with how they interpreted her in a classics style
5) Starla
6) Frosta
7) Goddess - I know people have had trouble with the quality control, but solely in terms of looks, I think she's great
8) Sorceress
9) Marlena/Captian Glenn
10) Shadow Weaver
11) Catra
12) Battleground Evil-Lyn
13) BG Evil-Lyn
14) Jewelstar
15) Bubble Power She-Ra - I would have liked her better if she also included the classic 'flippable' mask
16) Adora - Sorry, but it's hard for me to get past the 'granny panties' on this one

Still, I like them all quite a bit (granny panties and all) - but I do like some more than others.

[Blaster]

Teela
Shadow Weaver
Adora
Catra
She-Ra
Sorceress
Battle Ground Evil-Lynn
Frosta
Regular Evil-Lynn
Queen Marlena
The the star sisters I own but don't care about

I don't own the Goddess because of the breakage
and to me Battle ground Teela isn't Teela so I sold mine.

[Prahvus]

1) Shadow Weaver (the best)

2) Teela

3) Evil-Lyn

4) Adora

5) Queen Marlena

6) Catra

7) BG Teela

8) Sorceress

9) BG Evil-Lyn

10) BP She-Ra

11) She-Ra

12) Starla

13) Tallstar

14) Jewelstar

15) Frosta

16) Goddess (the worst)

[Barnster]

01. She-Ra (I took the body of version 2.0 and the head from 1.0 to create "Ultimate She-Ra")
02. Shadow Weaver
03. Teela
04. BG Evil-Lyn
05. Catra
06. Frosta
07. Sorceress
08. Starla
09. Adora
10. BG Teela
11. Marlena (I wish her eyes were painted better, but it is a minor issue)
12. Tallstar
13. Jewelstar
14. BP She-Ra (I just needed her parts)
15. Evil-Lyn (never liked her classic outfit)
16. Goddess (one of only three figures I do not own)

[Atomicdios]

1. Shadow Weaver ... perfect!
2. Goddess ... if you can over look the broken leg, awesome figure. Real nostalgic value.
3. Catra ... nailed her.
4. BG Evil Lyn ... love the colours.
5. Sorceress ... perfect if you loved filmation.

The Star Sisters are brutally ugly.
Frosta was my favourite POP and is an epic fail in MOTUC
Adora is meh

[skeletom]

1 Teela
2 Goddess
3 BG Evil-Lyn
4 BG Teela
5 Evil-Lyn
6 Sorceress
7 Shadow Weaver
8 She-Ra
9 Catra
10 Adora
11 Queen Marlena
12 BP She-Ra
13 Frosta
14 Tallstar
15 Jewelstar
16 Starla

[RocketPunch]

1) Shadow Weaver
2) Adora
3) Catra
4) Queen Marlena/Captain Glenn
5) Bubble Power She-Ra
6) Starla
7) Jewelstar
8) Tallstar
9) Evil-Lyn
10) Battleground Evil-Lyn
11) Teela
12) She-Ra
13) Battleground Teela
14) The Goddess
15) Sorceress
16) Frosta

[Haephestus]

1. Shadow Weaver
2. Bubble Power She-Ra
3. Catra
4. Adora
5. Teela
6. Evil-Lyn
7. She-Ra
8. Starla
9. Jewelstar
10. Tallstar
11. Queen Marlena
12. Frosta
13. Battleground Evil-Lyn
14. Battleground Teela
15. The Sorceress
16. The Goddess

[chrisware]

1. BG Evil-Lyn
2. Teela
3. TOD Sorceress
4. Adora
5. Evil-Lyn
6. Sorceress
7. BG Teela
8. Shadow Weaver
9. Catra
10. Marlena Glenn
11. Bubble Power She-Ra
12. She-Ra
13. Frosta
14. Goddess
15. Starla
16. Tallstar
17. Jewelstar

[ShowerPowerFrosta]

I don't have them all. I'll rank the ones I have.

1) Battleground Teela - Probably the closest thing I'll get to a Valkyrie figure. She's awesome, and I knew nothing about her until she was set to be released.

2) Catra - Might have been number one, but her loose knees make her hard to pose.

3) Starla - She's just so much fun to play with.

4) Bubble Power She-Ra - The added details make her stand out from the original She-Ra

5) The Sorceress - Even with the drums she looks really cool.

6) Adora - The first MOTUC I had. She's still really nice.

7) She-Ra - She stands in a corner with He-Man.

Mackenzie's on her way. I expect she's touring Sweden at the moment.

[shadowfall1976]

You don't have to own them to rank them, please rank all of them....I don't own Goddess, Marlena, BG Teela, Catra (yet), or the Star Sisters but I ranked them accordingly.

And I didn't count TOD Sorceress, because while she may be a convention exclusive, her time on Matty has not passed yet, so she is not available to everyone yet, even though a few online stores had her, but it was her convention stock, so I do not, and did not count her. Technically she is not available to everyone outside convention release until next month.

So please don't rank her in, even if you own her as of now.

[Barbecue17]

1.Teela- A nearly flawless figure with plenty of accessories and the ability to craft unique looks.

2.Marlena- Her green dress look is ok, but her retro space girl look makes her one of my favorite MOTUC figures ever. The only figure I bought two of to display both looks.

3.BP She-Ra- While you need to mix her to make a perfect She-Ra, I like the basics of this She-Ra better than the first release.

4.Adora- A very simple figure but an excellent looking one. Adora is a perfect example of taking a Filmation look and making it work in MOTUC.

5.BG Teela- Super cool with her barbarian look.

6.She-Ra- Great appearance with two alternate looks. Who doesn't love She-Ra?

7.BG Evil-Lyn- She is not the 200x Evil-Lyn and was an easy figure for Matty to pawn off on subscribers, but Evil-Lyn does look great with her unhelmeted head.

8.Frosta- With a few tweaks, she could have been at the top of this list.

9.Shadow Weaver- Nice figure. Very creepy.

10.Starla- Very unique figure. I love her colors, face sculpt, and hair.

11.Evil-Lyn- Love Evil-Lyn. I like thr bright yellow of her skin and her heavy eye shadow.

12.Sorceress- Looks fantastic. Wonky wings.

13.Goddess- Love the color of her skin. While she's a repaint, she looks so unique. Too bad she explodes.

14.Tallstar- OK head sculpt but overall I just find her pretty boring.

15.Catra- She looks ok (kind of ugly) but just doesn't interest me much. I wish her hand wasn't so awkward and gummy, though.

16.Jewelstar- Interesting concept but dull execution.

[ShowerPowerFrosta]

Oh, well in that case, Mackenzie is number 2. The rest as follows:

9) Battleground Evil-Lyn
10) Goddess
11) Shadow Weaver
12) Queen Marlena
13) Evil-Lyn
14) Tallstar
15) Jewelstar
16) Teela

[Fug-Lee-Faces]

1. Shadow Weaver ... perfect!
......
The Star Sisters are brutally ugly.
Frosta was my favourite POP and is an epic fail in MOTUC
Adora is meh

I think Shadow Weaver is perfect too. As for ALL the other female figs, I tend to think they are all rather Fuglee.
I have them all, and every time my wife looks at them she shakes her head. She has some choice words for whoever sculpted their faces.

[shadowfall1976]

Up to now, here are the rankings....counted from everyone who ranked all of them.

Top 5....
1) Teela
2) Shadow Weaver
3) Catra
4) BP She-Ra
5) BG Teela (tied, but tie breaker is last ranking position, Teela got a 2)

Top 10....
6) Evil-Lyn (tied, but tie breaker is last ranking position, EL got a 13)
7) She-Ra
8) BG Evil-Lyn
9) Frosta
10) Sorceress

Remaining....
11) Marlena
12) Starla
13) Adora
14) Tallstar
15) Goddess
16) Jewelstar

[WDWFreak53]

1. Shadow Weaver
2. Teela
3. Battleground Evil-Lyn
4. She-Ra/BP She-Ra Mashup
5. Catra
6. Marlena
7. Frosta
8. Battleground Teela
9. The Goddess
10. Starla
11. Sorceress
12. Temple of Darkness Sorceress
13. Evil-Lyn
14. Adora
15. Tallstar
16. Jewelstar

[shadowfall1976]

Each She-Ra has to be counted separate, guess that should have been stated before.....

And as I said TOD Sorceress won't be counted, she is not available widely yet to collectors
outside conventions, her Matty release date is December, if there be any left....

[MegaGearMax]

1) Battleground Teela
2) Teela
3) Catra
4) Battleground Evil-Lyn
5) Shadow Weaver
6) Adora
7) She-Ra
8) Sorceress
9) Starla
10) Bubble Power She-Ra
11) Frosta
12) Tallstar
13) Jewelstar
14) Queen Marlena
15) Evil-Lyn
16) Goddess

[iron_pride]

She-Ra
Adora
Tallstar
Sorceress
Shadow Weaver
Teela
Catra
Evil Lyn
Marlena
BP She-Ra
BG Teela
BG Evil Lyn
Frosta
Goddess
Starla
Jewelstar

[nicholighkun]

Basically I rank them by three categories. #1 is the 2.0 female buck, for it's posability. #2 are the original female buck figures. #3 are any figue (regardless of buck used) that has those abominable BG Teela thighs that don't allow thigh twist, as this hinders posability immensly. And I might even include a #4 category for Jewel star and Starla because they not only feature those aweful thighs, but they are also devoid of boot cuts, which gives them such a laughably hindered posability that I find myself fantasizing about creative ways to destroy them, even though I like the sculpts (but not Jewelstars paints). Posing these things is what makes them fun and gives you the ability to have a figure display that varies from others who have the exact same figures. I am actually angry when I see BG Teela's thighs used on a figure. I hate them with a passion.

Also I count Marlena as two different figures and BP She-ra and BP She-ra Filmation mod as two.

#1 She-Ra 2.0 (BP She-Ra with Filmation head and sword, minus BP armor)
#2 Catra
#3 Shadow Weaver
#4 Frosta
#5 Sorceress
#6 Evil-Lynn
#7 Adora
#8 BG Evil-Lynn
#9 Teela
#10 Marlena
#11 Captain Glenn
#12 BP She-Ra
#13 She-Ra
#14 Tallstar
#15 BG Teela
#16 Starla
#17 Jewelstar
#666 GodLess

[Stratos*Major]

Teela (I think the best scuplted and exicuted female figure of the line.)
She-Ra (Hello...)
Adora (I think she came out great!)
Catra (Squish hand and all she is a wonderful figure that FINALY has her Filmation look! I think Catra's Filmation look KILS the toy version)
BG Evil Lyn (I never got the yellow skin...the ONE variant I bought!)
Shadow Weaver (I am happy they didnt try to put too muh into her sulpt and end up over doing her. She came out great, especially for a figure in a long dress...that floats!!)
BP She-Ra (as a variant...she made it this high because of the white clothing and the split dress...)
Soreress (She could have made it over BGEL....BUT those drums make her less of a flawless figure)
BG Teela (I see her as a new character. She is not Teela...shes some random barbarian woman who has great strength(Not GC strength) but an fight along with the MOTU.)
Evil Lynn (yellow...really??...)
Marlena (Never had to have her. She ranked higher than the others do to the quality and thought to the figure)
Tall Star (the best star sister by far...had her outfit been altered or different and the colors too...her fae suplt is great for sure)
Frosta (Poorly finsihed...is you call it finished)
Starla (Now way...she looks like a 80s fast food chick who should be on rollerskates)
Jewelstar (Oh man...wow...is it the fae sulpt or the paint....is it both? MORE crystals really would have made this figure something cool. The whole Dune looking body armour...no thanks.)
Goddess (Not into variants. Im not a fan of the whole clear plastic (unless its for Crystar or maybe used on a figure like Jewelstar other wise it makes no sense to me...have not nor do I plan on getting this figure also because of the possibility or breakage)

[The All American]

The females in this line are incredible! I can't wait until we get to the rest of the POP gals!

1. Teela
2. Battleground Teela
3. She-Ra
4. Catra
5. Adora
6. The Sorceress
7. Frosta
8. Evil-Lyn
9. Tallstar
10. Starla
11. Bubble Power She-Ra
12. Queen Marlena
13. Battleground Evil-Lyn
14. Shadow Weaver
15. The Goddess
16. Jewelstar

[slackrguy]

Marlena
Adora
Teela
Sorceress
Goddess
Starla
BP She-Ra
Jewelstar
Shadow Weaver
Frosta
Catra
BG Evil-Lyn
Evil-Lyn
Tallstar
BG Teela
She-Ra