VOTE! Crown the Champion of Redesign Challenge #104 - KARATTI!

**Pyre** · January 23, 2013, 04:17pm

Alright Folks!
Here we are.

Time to vote on the pieces you have seen come to life in Redesign Challenge #104.

Tells us which artist you think hit home with their rendition of a newly designed Karatti from the New Adventures of He-Man series.

Cast your vote and feel free to critique, give props, or tell us about your personal perspectives on the pieces!

1) image removed.

2) BLAST ATTAK

3) CHARLIE BROWN

4) MONIKASVO

5) NIKI

6) NIMRODOR

7) PYRE

8) ZARGON

**Niki** · January 23, 2013, 04:36pm

I didn´t realize how many redesigns there have been i honestly thought there were even less!

Still a lot of creativity... and i´m torn...as always.

I can´t decide yet, need to sleep over it!

**wolfsfang** · January 23, 2013, 07:48pm

I voted for me.

I didn't enter but I always vote for me.

(okay I voted for Pyre...but in my heart I was voting for me)

**Crusader** · January 23, 2013, 09:09pm

My vote goes to Blast Attack's beautiful rendering.

**MLHumble** · January 23, 2013, 10:16pm

Originally Posted by Crusader

My vote goes to Blast Attack's beautiful rendering.

As did mine. But they are all great!

**Pyre** · January 24, 2013, 02:02am

I just have to say, I am personaly impressed with Niki's design. Wow, way to put your style to the max. It's gonna be my desktop wallpaprer for a while. Great work Niki!

Blast attak...smooth bro. Very smooth.

**Niki** · January 26, 2013, 02:49pm

WOW! Pyre, i´m speechless! Thank you!

I still don´t know whom i gonna vote for.

Voting for myself is no option, that´s almost like cheating if you ask me...

Knowing Blast attaks picture is an amazing work in progress, makes it even harder to vote for him as i hoped he would finish it...

Nimrodors action pose and clean lines look great as a picture, his design is to much earth samurai for my taste tough...

Pyres redesign is also very samurai but your details are as always astounding, Karattis face mask alone looks menacing....

decisions, decisions, decisions....life isn´t fair!

**Pyre** · January 26, 2013, 05:41pm

Welcome good sir.

And hey brother, if you think your concept is the best...vote for it!!!

I always vote for my personal fav, and if I truely honestly feel mine is the best, I have no qualms about placing the proper vote that says so.

Also folks, I should make mention that adam fro facebook's design had to be removed per maderator request. Sorry, I can't get into detail about why but that,s why the image is no longer viewable.

Does anyone think we should restart the voting thread to be fair to people who cast their votesfor a design that is no longer admissable? Post your opinion here to vote.

Originally Posted by Niki

WOW! Pyre, i´m speechless! Thank you!

I still don´t know whom i gonna vote for.

Voting for myself is no option, that´s almost like cheating if you ask me...

Knowing Blast attaks picture is an amazing work in progress, makes it even harder to vote for him as i hoped he would finish it...

Nimrodors action pose and clean lines look great as a picture, his design is to much earth samurai for my taste tough...

Pyres redesign is also very samurai but your details are as always astounding, Karattis face mask alone looks menacing....

decisions, decisions, decisions....life isn´t fair!

**Niki** · January 26, 2013, 05:53pm

Originally Posted by Pyre

Welcome good sir.

And hey brother, if you think your concept is the best...vote for it!!!

I always vote for my personal fav, and if I truely honestly feel mine is the best, I have no qualms about placing the proper vote that says so.

Also folks, I should make mention that adam fro facebook's design had to be removed per maderator request. Sorry, I can't get into detail about why but that,s why the image is no longer viewable.

Does anyone think we should restart the voting thread to be fair to people who cast their votesfor a design that is no longer admissable? Post your opinion here to vote.

"Lady Karatti" received 5 votes and everyone so far got a vote. There were 41 votes so far and i think we would lose more than we would gain from those five votes.

If those five could write they voted for "her" and than write a private message to you or Patrick than you guys can add them in the end, i can honestly say i would trust both of you. if the voters don´t want to put their votes openly in this thread.

Deleting the poll isn´t necessary if you ask me.

**Charlie Brown** · January 27, 2013, 11:33am

i do agree with niki 'bout the votes for "lady karatti".

personally, i voted for blast attak (don't forget to post him finished, bro!!

), but love many ideas and details from
others too.

**Niki** · January 27, 2013, 12:52pm

...weird...

and maybe i was wrong, Adams "Lady Karatti" got two more votes even though there is no picture to be seen anymore...

And it´s clearly stated that he/she is out....

Right now there are 45 votes and Blast attak and Pyre both received 11 vote and lead the poll, maybe you should start a new poll between those two designs and that would give Blast attak a chance to FINISH his !!!!!!

**He-Breuly** · January 27, 2013, 02:54pm

I gave my vote to Pyre

**Pyre** · January 27, 2013, 09:21pm

Ok folks,

Here's what I,ve decided for the removed image.

Although the image is no longer viewable on the org, it has aquired admiration and therefore, votes. It seemingly is continuing to do so, perhaps because you can view the inage on the redesign challenge facebook page. For this challenge, the votes for the missing piece are still game, and the piece is still elligeable to win the challenge.

However, given this unprecidented situation, new rules are hearby instated regarding the redesign challenge for aritists who submit pieces from sites outside of He-man.org:

1) Artists who have been banned from He-man.org forums are not elligeable to submit a piece into the redesign challenge; including the use of our facebook page, Deviant art, or any other image storage website.

2) Should an inelligeable piece be unkowingly submitted into the challenge, the voting thread/poll will be closed and thusly restarted so that voters will have the opportunity to have their votes count towards a winning design.

I hope that sounds fair to everyone who enjoys the redesign challenge with respect for the rules our moderators must enforce

PYRE

**Pyre** · January 27, 2013, 10:37pm

Wolfsfang and He-Breuly,

Thanks brothers

**Ulisses31** · January 28, 2013, 08:51am

Oh! The drama! I vote for Facebook! hahahahahaha..... I´m taking a long time away from these, if someone want I have some threads were I show my art. Sad for Pyre and Patrick, were all the fun gone? No need to reply. Thanks for everyone efforts.

**Niki** · February 1, 2013, 01:00pm

WOW!

I just checked and saw my picture got 10 votes, i never got that many!

Thanks guys, that really lightened up my day

**Patreek** · February 12, 2013, 09:35pm

So with it so close and with the issue with the one entry not being valid i think we'll do a final top three run off poll stay tuned

View Poll Results: My personal favorite redesign was done by:

Thread: VOTE! Crown the Champion of Redesign Challenge #104 - KARATTI!

Thread Tools

Search Thread

Display

VOTE! Crown the Champion of Redesign Challenge #104 - KARATTI!

Posting Permissions