Results 1 to 14 of 14

Thread: A cool review of GI Joe: Retaliation (and new hope for He-Man being good)

Hybrid View

  1. #1
    Heroic Warrior Ivan's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2003
    Location
    New York
    Posts
    1,529

    A cool review of GI Joe: Retaliation (and new hope for He-Man being good)

    I just stumbled upon the io9 review of the new GI Joe movie, and the way it's described really lifted my spirits and rekindled my hopes for the upcoming He-Man movie. I know people are concerned about Jon Chu directing it, but some of the things here are exactly what I would like He-Man movie to be and I hope he captures it again.

    Retaliation feels like G.I. Joe — not like the cartoon, not just like the comic, but what people loved about the franchise (especially the toys). Director Jon M. Chu gets it. It’s like he made a checklist about what made G.I. Joe special, and decided Retaliation was gonna have all of it.
    Now that would be awesome for He-Man. With all the canons around, early mini comics, cartoon, toys and packaging tidbits, 200x, Star Comics, DC comics... there is really no one true source. But there is this feeling we all have when we think of MOTU, there is some essence we all remember. And it seems like he tried to capture exactly that in the GI Joe movie. Now, granted, I haven't actually seen the movie, nor am I a GI Joe fan, so I can't really say how successful it really is, but the guys over at io9 seem pretty impressed. I love how they described that the movie is like a kid's play come to life.

    Now, another thing - people often say they want the new MOTU movie to be gritty, realistic... people talk of The Dark Knight or 300 when they describe their preferred style. I have never been a fan of that, honestly. Dark Knight is awesome for itself, but that's not MOTU for me. MOTU always has been and IMO it always needs to be a little goofy, a little out of this world (and out of this logic). It needs to be fun! The review lists this as one of the major selling points of the movie "A simultaneously goofy and cool Cobra plot to take over the world" That is EXACTLY what I would love the movie to be - fun, action packed, and preserve some of the silliness of the original material. The last thing MOTU needs is to take itself too seriously and become just another pretentious forgettable summer flick.

    Between the entertainment on screen and the brisk pacing, there’s practically no time to think about the film’s plot holes and problems [...] when I realized them, I thought, “Well, that doesn’t make much sense, but I’m having such a good time. Who cares?”

    [...]

    Retaliation isn’t a perfect movie by any means — no one’s going to confuse it with Citizen Kane — but it’s a completely sold action movie while being a thoughtful love letter to G.I. Joe fans. But it’s not slavish devotion — Chu truly cherry picks the essence of G.I. Joe, and brings out its best to the big screen in a way that should entertain hardcore fans and mass audiences alike.
    Now, that is exactly what I want. That is what has me all excited again for the MOTU movie which - I must say - I started to lose hope for. If he has a similar approach to MOTU, and I don't see why not, and if he actually succeeds in it it would be so amazing.

    I used to be a little skeptical about Jon Chu, but now I'm sold. I can't wait to see GI Joe: Retaliation and if this review is an accurate portrayal then I'm all for Chu directing MOTU!


    sorry, I can't post a link to the review because of some inappropriate language, but you guys can just go to io9 and find it.

  2. #2
    Heroic Warrior Krueger's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2008
    Location
    England, UK
    Posts
    2,847
    The “professional” critics are tearing it a new one, whereas a lot of the “fanboy-centric” critics seem to be giving it high praise.

  3. #3
    Eternian Pimp PIMPS ADAM's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2009
    Location
    S.E. Aurora,Colorado
    Posts
    814
    I think part of the problem is people want properties to be so believable to the point they ruin the movie going experience from the start. If the Motu movie is set on Eternia, I don't want hear this madness of...That's impossible duh!! Anything goes in fiction. I like to dumb myself down before any movie and make an opinion based on it after that, I'm never trying to find who the killer is, what are the motives etc.? That's the director job to tell the story. I’m not a die-hard Joe fan but I'll give it a chance and any Motu movie I’ll support it and hopefully fall in love with it. Ivan are catching a Red eye to Power-Con this year again? Me and the wife a hold the cab for you again at the airport.
    “You don't stop playing because you grow old you grow old because you stop playing.” George Benard Shaw.

  4. #4
    Heroic Warrior Ivan's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2003
    Location
    New York
    Posts
    1,529
    Quote Originally Posted by PIMPS ADAM View Post
    I think part of the problem is people want properties to be so believable to the point they ruin the movie going experience from the start. If the Motu movie is set on Eternia, I don't want hear this madness of...That's impossible duh!! Anything goes in fiction. I like to dumb myself down before any movie and make an opinion based on it after that, I'm never trying to find who the killer is, what are the motives etc.? That's the director job to tell the story. I’m not a die-hard Joe fan but I'll give it a chance and any Motu movie I’ll support it and hopefully fall in love with it.
    Agreed. Though, "dumbing down" sounds a little negative, but it's really about suspension of disbelief when it's warranted. Take a look at some of the great stories that survived the test of time - myths, fairy tales, old epic poems - they all sound a little stupid for a modern person. Yeah, the princess was locked in a tower and she let her hair down for the prince to climb and rescue her. What kind of a plan is that? Even if she really had a hair that long, how painful would that be for her? Still, nobody cares, and they love that story because the story creates a rich, interesting, engaging world you can escape into and fantasize. I hope they keep that in He-Man.

    Quote Originally Posted by PIMPS ADAM View Post
    Ivan are catching a Red eye to Power-Con this year again? Me and the wife a hold the cab for you again at the airport.
    Hey, yes, hold the cab! I actually just booked a flight this morning! I'll be there on Friday evening (landing around 1030), hopefully there will be a mixer downstairs again. Sorry, everyone, for going of topic here

  5. #5
    Heroic Master of Maturity SCB's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    Location
    Santa Monica, CA
    Posts
    7,651
    My review of the new movie

    Well after a nine month reshoot, the sequel finally comes out. If you followed why the movie was reshot regarding Tatum's character, then you'll wonder why they bothered reshooting the movie in the first place. Seriously.

    On to the movie. It's average at best. The comedy, action, emotional moments all fall flat. Seemed like the director could not solve the puzzle of making Bruce Willis and The Rock interesting in an action movie other than showing up on screen.

    I'd say the best parts involve Storm Shadow and he's barely in it. They also improved upon Cobra Commander now that he looks like Cobra Commander. And lastly Adrian Pallicki looks great on camera. Those are the positives, other than Firefly kind of being cool at times.

    The movie is easily better than the first, but only because it was missing many of the poor elements. It's entertaining, but forgettable. Which is a shame because this lightweight is directing the next He- Man and my expectations are extremely low now.

    See it for fun, but you're not missing anything.

  6. #6
    Completely Serious. Bri-Man's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2011
    Location
    right behind you...
    Posts
    645
    Personally, i thought The Dark Knight was incredibly fun. But I get it, when most people use that word, what they usually mean is “lighthearted”.

    The problem there is that lighthearted can so easily become campy, especially in the hands of a novice. Comic relief is fine, but the characters should still act like people. That was what TDK did right. There was still a lot of over the top comic book quality in TDK- but it took place in a world of consequences.

    This is where I think the latest joe film falls short. Granted, it’s miles ahead of the first film, but it could have been much more. I love the filmation he-man cartoon (if you couldn’t tell), and I love the adam west batman series. That doesn’t mean I would want to see that in a major motion picture. I think the big screen should be the place where a writer and director really try to elevate the material above the “this is just for kids” limitations placed on the original source media.

    I feel that movies that don’t take themselves seriously are the ones that become forgettable. There’s a reason that TDK became an instant classic of the genre.

    But he-man is not batman. There are other movies that excel far better than G.I. Joe: Retaliation at finding the right balance of character driven narrative, action, humor, comic relief and supernatural elements and take themselves seriously:

    The avengers
    The Indiana jones series
    The lord of the rings series
    Star Wars

    Above all, I want a MOTU movie that is character driven. I want it to be emotionally and intellectually stirring with a story that feels relevant to the human condition. There’s no reason that it can’t be a critically acclaimed classic film- if done right. I’m not sure chu is up to that. If the script is awesome maybe that will help, but that’s just one element. Maybe it will benefit chu that MOTU is not a sequel, so he’ll be more free to let the creative juices flow.
    FILMATION
    PRESENTS
    .:*~*:Thank You, Lou Scheimer...and Good Journey:*~*:.
    ...For Every Destination is but a Doorway to Another...
    The Time Has Come for Crackers The Clown and Chef Allen in MOTUC!

  7. #7
    Heroic Warrior yeahthatsme1973's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2011
    Location
    Chicago area
    Posts
    348
    SCB I agree with everything you said except I enjoyed the first movie much more than this one. There were several laugh out loud moments for me at how bad the dialogue was. Some of the scenery shots in the mountains were pretty good. The action sequences up until that last one were good too. That last one though. Gah. It felt like they ran out of money or something. Below average movie for me. C-

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •