Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 25 of 28

Thread: Interview - Janice Varney-Hamlin-former Mattel Director of WW Marketing Fashion Dolls

  1. #1
    Hexcellent Horror Hostess
    Penny Dreadful's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2002
    Location
    Massachusetts, US
    Posts
    4,554

    Interview - Janice Varney-Hamlin-former Mattel Director of WW Marketing Fashion Dolls



    Interview with Janice Varney-Hamlin, Former Mattel Director of Worldwide Marketing Fashion Dolls

    Interview with Janice Varney-Hamlin
    By Danielle Gelehrter
    March 29, 2015


    Over the years, we’ve heard from many of the people behind the He-Man and the Masters of the Universe toyline. We’ve also heard from many of the people who worked on the He-Man and She-Ra cartoons, comics, and movie, but we’ve very rarely heard from the major forces responsible for the Princess of Power toyline. Fortunately for She-Ra and He-Man fans, Janice Varney-Hamlin graciously agreed to the following interview. Janice is a veteran Senior marketing, brand and business development executive. She is the executive Vice President of Varney Consulting and has worked as a Franchise Manager and Developer for the Disney ABC Television Group, Vice President of Retail Development and Product Development at Time-Warner, and of course as Director of Worldwide Marketing – Fashion Dolls for Mattel. Janice was one of the main masterminds behind the Princess of Power toyline during her tenure at Mattel in the 1980s.

    What was your position at Mattel?

    My position at Mattel during this time frame was Director of Worldwide Marketing Fashion Dolls. I was responsible for Barbie and other fashion doll categories.

    Can you describe what your job entailed?

    In my job I had worldwide P&L responsibility for Fashion Dolls, building brand plans, developing and implementing growth strategies based on consumer insights and marketing A&U. I was also responsible for advertising, promotion and PR across the brands. At that time, Mattel had a matrix management system so teams reported into their discipline managers and into the category manager, of which I was one. For example, engineers reported into VP of Engineering, but also supported the marketing category manager on category teams.

    How were you involved in the Princess of Power brand, specifically?

    I created the doll line, She-Ra, Princess of Power, developed the position, worked on every aspect of the program. It was based on the inspiration and hugely popular He-Man. The collection was born as a strategy in creating a flanker brand for Barbie. After looking at the fashion doll market, I noticed that when competitive fashion dolls entered the fashion doll arena the entire fashion doll category expanded. And when they left the category, Barbie business gobbled up those excess dollars. So flanker brands as they were called then, were constructed and introduced to grow the industry. Barbie sales had flattened out at the time, so introducing a competitive fashion doll line that we owned should expand the size of the entire category and allow the Barbie business to grow. In order to do that, the fashion doll line Mattel introduced had to address a play pattern upon which Barbie could not deliver…action adventure and of course with fashion and beauty. Another was family, mom with children, which the Heart Family addressed.


    Initially, She-Ra design concepts started out in the Boys Products department, but She-Ra was later taken over by the Girls Products department. Can you talk about the changes that were implemented once Girls Products took over?


    That is not exactly accurate. One of the first lines that I worked on at Mattel was a female fashion action line, but it did not get placement at retail so it was dropped. When we opted to reintroduce the idea, we decided to link the collection to the extremely successful line, He-Man, to give it credibility and get retail placement. The boys toy executive fought to have it in their line since we were leveraging their brand, but after the first look of the doll, no articulation, no hair, no fashion, not attractive at all, the collection was put back in the girls line. The line was not called She-Ra then, we renamed the female character, added hair, beautiful costumes and appropriate girl relatable features to make it a meaningful brand.

    But, She-Ra definitely came from the girl’s category as we were looking at inventor concepts already. As a matter of fact, the boys category fought us all the way and was convinced that the ebbing of He-Man sales was directly linked to the introduction of She-Ra, Princess of Power.

    So, She-Ra looked different and had a different name when the boys dept. worked on it. Do you recall what she was called then or what she looked like?

    She was a 3 or 5 inch scale and battle worthy. I cannot remember what her name was though.

    Can you recall the names of other people involved with She-Ra and what their involvement was?

    Myself and Cathy Larsen were instrumental in breaking the product line and the category together. Eventually, after moving on to other businesses, other managers inherited it.

    The She-Ra Princess of Power cartoon series from Filmation was very popular. How closely did Mattel work with Filmation on She-Ra?

    Mattel approached HB to develop the She-Ra animated series. Mattel, Cathy, and myself, actually created the storylines for the books being published by then, Western Publishing. We wanted to mirror those stories in the television series. However, if we did not have an enemy more notorious in animation, She-Ra would not seem as powerful, so we followed Filmation’s lead on this element. Villains were led by Hordak, and Catra was the evil version of the female action leader and worked for Hordak. Catra was beautiful, but had the ability to scratch her (She-Ra).

    Were there any characters you remember that didn’t make it into production in the toy line?

    Yes, there were about 30 characters developed, but only those that tested well in consumer research were introduced.

    I know it was 30 years ago, but do you recall any of the characters that "didn't make it?"


    I really can't remember the ones who did not make it.

    Do you have any funny or interesting memories about working on the brand?

    Yes.

    We decided that we wanted to do a live action traveling event for retails in which She-Ra would show up to battle Catra. I was interviewing some very beautiful models in my office at Mattel in El Segundo to play these roles. We asked them to get in costume and write some lines that we role as part of the play. So the real life Catra and She-Ra and several versions of them, were in and out of my office. Each time I opened my office door I would find five guys hanging out in the hallway or suspiciously walking by the office to check out the talent. Pretty funny.

    We would sit in my office and come up with characters, names, and features inspired by Greek Mythology. Some of those were pretty fun to work on. You can find a list of the characters on Wikipedia.

    Thank you so much to Janice for taking the time out of her very busy schedule to reminisce a bit about her vital impact on the Princess of Power brand!
    Last edited by Penny Dreadful; March 31, 2015 at 01:50pm.
    PENNY DREADFUL'S SHILLING SHOCKERS
    Hosted horror, sci-fi, suspense, and fantasy films!
    On television scare-waves throughout Haunted New England

    http://www.shillingshockers.com

    TERROR AT COLLINWOOD
    A podcast dedicated to the classic gothic television series, Dark Shadows

    https://www.terroratcollinwood.com/

  2. #2
    Heroic Warrior Lich Leech's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2012
    Location
    Battle Ram Blog
    Posts
    4,456
    Neat, I love these interviews. I wonder if there was any truth to the idea that She-Ra was cannibalizing MOTU sales. Maybe somewhat, but probably not a lot.

  3. #3
    He-Man historian
    Jukka's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2000
    Location
    Hämeenlinna, Finland
    Posts
    14,469
    Thank you again for your tireless work with doing these Interviews and research to the MOTU/POP Histories, Danielle!
    He-Man & She-Ra fan, writer to official Dark Horse MOTU/POP books

    · ToonJukka - Youtube Channel with He-Man/She-Ra videos; Origins, Trivia, Top5 lists and more!

  4. #4
    Council Elder Tallstar's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2001
    Posts
    23,628
    Thank you for doing this. I was so excited when I saw this thread from the main page, that I raced to sign in and comment. :P Just about to read this goodness.

  5. #5
    Heroic Warrior headache79's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2013
    Location
    Portland, OR
    Posts
    156
    Quote Originally Posted by Lich Leech View Post
    Neat, I love these interviews. I wonder if there was any truth to the idea that She-Ra was cannibalizing MOTU sales. Maybe somewhat, but probably not a lot.
    I know that once She-Ra came along, I was far more interested in POP than MOTU at that point. Before between my brother and I we got everything MOTU, afterward he got MOTU and I got POP, so there was at least half of the MOTU coming into our house. The only MOTU stuff I got after POP came out was a Hordak, Mantenna, the Sorceress, Modulok, Grizzlor, and the Fright Zone -- and all of those were needed (in my mind) for She-Ra.

    I do wish there was someone to find the concepts of the unproduced characters she referred to.

  6. #6
    TWIGGET ENTHUSIAST! Swifty's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2011
    Location
    Cromwell, CT USA
    Posts
    2,442
    This is really great stuff Danielle! I am dying to know who those dropped characters were. I hope we can one day we can dig deep enough to find that type of information out!
    IT'S TIME FOR MOTUC TO GO GREEN … INCLUDE THE TWIGGETS IN 2019!!!

    Inspector Darkney Master Sebrian Gleep Spyster Admiral Scurvey Squall Starburst She-Ra ScratchinSound Catra Grot Caz Drissi Crystal Moonbeam/Sun Dancer Meliac NA Adam Chef Allen Songster Scrollos Kowla Red Eye Brightmoon Palace Guards

  7. #7
    Searchin' My Soul DisneyBoy's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2001
    Posts
    4,382
    Me too, Swifty.

    Although this comment makes me smile for all the wrong reasons:

    As a matter of fact, the boys category fought us all the way and was convinced that the ebbing of He-Man sales was directly linked to the introduction of She-Ra, Princess of Power.
    So apparently even the boys in the high-rises had to blame She-Ra for He-Man's downfall Now I know where the fanbase got that attitude from.

    Thanks for the interview! Really nice to hear from the people who were there.

  8. #8
    Liberty, justice, peace. The All American's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2010
    Location
    Baltimore, MD
    Posts
    3,858
    Thank you for doing this interview!

    I grew up with a huge POP fan (my sister), so I have a great love for this kind of stuff.


    Quote Originally Posted by headache79 View Post
    I do wish there was someone to find the concepts of the unproduced characters she referred to.
    Yes! As fans, this long lost information would be great to find out. Maybe "The Power & Honor Foundation" will be able to uncover something?

  9. #9
    Heroic Warrior
    Join Date
    Sep 2008
    Posts
    1,957
    Great interview.

    Does anyone know what this refers to: "You can find a list of the characters on Wikipedia". Is that a list of the characters in She-Ra, a list of Greek mythological characters or a list of the characters from She-Ra together with the Greek mythological character on which they were based? If it's the latter, I can't seem to find that on wikipedia.

    It's odd that the boys category simply didn't make their own version of She-Ra (and whoever else they wanted), unless they weren't allowed to. A "She-Ra" that had the same aesthetic as Teela, Evil-Lyn and Sorceress would have been pretty cool. The She-Ra proto-type with the sculpted/attached tiara certainly seemed to be closer to Teela than the final She-Ra figure.

  10. #10
    Council Elder Darkspecter's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2004
    Location
    Ontario, Canada
    Posts
    15,363
    Oh man, I would LOVE it if we could find the characters that weren't produced because "they didn't test well." So much of PoP is a mystery. I wish all the info could be uncovered like it has been for MOTU. I wonder if she or Cathy have anything from their days working on PoP?

    EDIT: I'm also very confused when it comes to the look of the PoP characters that came first. From reading this interview, I'm under the impression that she and Cathy created She-Ra and their looks, then Filmation had a different idea, they listened, and decided to go with that for the cartoon? Maybe? Anyone?
    Last edited by Darkspecter; March 31, 2015 at 10:04pm.
    Take part in Illumina Day! Let people know who she is and help get her in MOTUC.

    http://motuc-illumina.proboards.com/...cgi?board=talk

    You can join the Illumina Facebook page here!

    https://www.facebook.com/Illumina.Sleetah

  11. #11
    Hexcellent Horror Hostess
    Penny Dreadful's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2002
    Location
    Massachusetts, US
    Posts
    4,554
    Quote Originally Posted by Darkspecter View Post
    Oh man, I would LOVE it if we could find the characters that weren't produced because "they didn't test well." So much of PoP is a mystery. I wish all the info could be uncovered like it has been for MOTU. I wonder if she or Cathy have anything from their days working on PoP?
    I asked Janice if she kept anything and, alas, she did not. She said she has two She-Ra magazines in storage and that's all.

    I once had a private conversation with former Mattel design executive & Senior VP of marketing Judy Shackelford (who worked on POP) and she also mentioned that she didn't keep anything. Bummer.

    Hopefully some of that stuff will turn up one day.
    PENNY DREADFUL'S SHILLING SHOCKERS
    Hosted horror, sci-fi, suspense, and fantasy films!
    On television scare-waves throughout Haunted New England

    http://www.shillingshockers.com

    TERROR AT COLLINWOOD
    A podcast dedicated to the classic gothic television series, Dark Shadows

    https://www.terroratcollinwood.com/

  12. #12
    TWIGGET ENTHUSIAST! Swifty's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2011
    Location
    Cromwell, CT USA
    Posts
    2,442
    I'm assuming a lot of the dropped characters were from the cartoon who just didn't lend themselves well to the style of the line, like Madame Razz and Shadow Weaver perhaps. That's what I really want to find out.
    IT'S TIME FOR MOTUC TO GO GREEN … INCLUDE THE TWIGGETS IN 2019!!!

    Inspector Darkney Master Sebrian Gleep Spyster Admiral Scurvey Squall Starburst She-Ra ScratchinSound Catra Grot Caz Drissi Crystal Moonbeam/Sun Dancer Meliac NA Adam Chef Allen Songster Scrollos Kowla Red Eye Brightmoon Palace Guards

  13. #13
    Heroic Warrior mykan's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2009
    Location
    Saint Petersburg, FL
    Posts
    395
    Thank you for doing this interview, Ms. Gelehrter! It's always great to get more insight into the history of POP.

    Unfortunately, I think I'm more confused than ever, and am left with more questions.

    Many of us were under the impression that POP evolved directly out of MOTU as an answer to the lack of female presence in the line, as well as there being a significant number of girls that were buying product. Teela and Evil-Lyn just weren't enough, and so Mattel proceeded to work with Filmation (who also believed there should be a female He-Man) to develop this new "faction" of female warriors. Ultimately, the development that's been shown to us seems to point in the direction that POP started off as being a sub faction in MOTU (similar to how POG was going to be). The Horde was already being developed as a third faction of evil, so it made since to pit them against this fourth faction of heroic warrior maidens. Filmation developed the story, and the look of the characters went back and forth between Mattel and Filmation. At some point, the "Barbie People" got involved and broke the female faction off into a separate line. This is presumably where POP changed in design, style and theme.

    Ms. Varney-Hamlin states that POP was created as an answer to extend Mattel, and Barbie, into other girls' markets. I suspect that the history of POP as we know it IS accurate, as well as this former Mattel Director's account.

    Here's my theory: In the interest of expanding options in the girls' market, Ms. Varney-Hamlin saw an opportunity to take the female faction being developed in MOTU and create an entire toy line around it. BECAUSE Barbie is Mattel's flagship, and needed help at the time, it made sense to transfer the POP faction to the girls department. Though all the development for POP had been done in the Mattel/Filmation R&D, the Fashion Dolls Department did a "soft reboot" to ensure that the product was more girl-oriented. THIS would explain the disparate nature of the cartoon in comparison to the toys, mini comics and books that were being made for the POP toy line.

    It just never made since how She-Ra and all the POP characters looked so different from their cartoon and Style Guide appearances. And why were Catra and Entrapta the only villains? WHY did you have to buy two separate toy lines to represent the cartoon? Why were there the two disparate tones of a go get 'em warrior maiden vs the posh princess n' friends with the one jealous friend?

    Clearly the Dolls Department was of a culture that just felt that what was developed for POP by the boys team just wouldn't work at all in the girls market. This is unfortunate to a degree - POP probably should've remained in MOTU so that BOTH He-Man and She-Ra characters could've enjoyed longer success, but this is hindsight...
    Celebrate Princess of Power with Us!
    http://www.facebook.com/messages/103...P/288325415324
    Check out POP videos, reviews and toy checklists.
    http://popclassics.weebly.com

  14. #14
    +2 Against Harpies Sword2Blanket's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2008
    Posts
    1,247
    I'm glad Ms. Janice Varney-Hamlin took the time to do this interview, and I'm glad our resident good witch, P Dread, brought it to us.

    Sadly, though, I often find these interviews depressing. Finding out that a brand that you've loved for most of your life was created with the mindset that it would merely be a sacrificial lamb to feed and further bloat the Barbie beast is kinda disgusting.

    She-Ra seems like one of those cases where the brand was fairly successful despite all of the original creators' efforts to make it terrible. Thank God for Filmation and thank God that Mattel "followed Filmation's lead on this element". If not, I don't think anyone would know who She-Ra was.

    Quote Originally Posted by mykan View Post
    This is unfortunate to a degree - POP probably should've remained in MOTU so that BOTH He-Man and She-Ra characters could've enjoyed longer success, but this is hindsight...
    This is perhaps the greatest tragedy in all of toydom.

    I still to this day don't understand what Mattel was trying to do with its PoP toy line. Even after it's explained to me by someone who has first hand knowledge, it doesn't make sense to me on any level. Had PoP been properly interwoven into Motu.... oh what could have been....

  15. #15
    Council Elder Tallstar's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2001
    Posts
    23,628
    Here's something to think about: Would there even have been a She-Ra, Princess of Power toy line and a separate cartoon if Janice and Cathy didn't put the wheels in motion to create a new fashion-action brand? Piecing together the sequence events in these interviews, it seems as though the "boys department" only became interested in expanding MOTU with a line of females after hearing that the "girls department" wanted to do it. And if "PoP" had remained in the boys category, with the rugged prototype as the approved design, would it have led to Princess of Power as we know it today? I don't think so. The names and designs would probably be very different. Would the separate PoP Filmation cartoon exist? I dunno.

    Anyhoo...I still love classic toy PoP regardless of what the motivations were behind the creation of it.

  16. #16
    Heroic Warrior mykan's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2009
    Location
    Saint Petersburg, FL
    Posts
    395
    Quote Originally Posted by Tallstar View Post
    Here's something to think about: Would there even have been a She-Ra, Princess of Power toy line and a separate cartoon if Janice and Cathy didn't put the wheels in motion to create a new fashion-action brand? Piecing together the sequence events in these interviews, it seems as though the "boys department" only became interested in expanding MOTU with a line of females after hearing that the "girls department" wanted to do it. And if "PoP" had remained in the boys category, with the rugged prototype as the approved design, would it have led to Princess of Power as we know it today? I don't think so. The names and designs would probably be very different. Would the separate PoP Filmation cartoon exist? I dunno.
    The question is: Did Cathy and Janice indeed create She-Ra from scratch, or was there a proto She-Ra in development in the Boys Department - that was then transferred to Dolls? From these interviews, it's clear that the Princess of Power toy line was indeed a product of the Girls Department. But it makes sense that "She-Ra" was in development for the MOTU brand since the Horde became so deeply rooted in her origin. IF She-Ra was exclusively a girls dept creation, I doubt the Horde would have been involved, and the marketing for POP would have been more consistent in the promotion of girls play. The Horde simply didn't lend itself to girls play, and the cartoon was a stark contrast to the POP toy line.

    Perhaps She-Ra would've looked different, and I doubt there would have been a separate cartoon series if she remained in MOTU. But the basic elements for the character would've been there - she would've been He-Man's long lost twin sister, who was a former member of the Evil Horde. Why do I believe this? Across every body of fiction involving She-Ra's origin, she is He-Man's sister who was abducted by the Horde - so this was most likely a part of her creation from the very beginning...

    Honestly, I think that leaving He-Man's sister in MOTU would've been best for both He-Man and She-Ra or "He-Ra".... Season 3 of He-Man and the Masters of the Universe may have been retitled "Masters of the Universe" now that He-Man's sister was joining him. The Horde would become a prominent enemy that fought against He-Man, his sister and Skeletor. Episodes would probably alternate between groups of characters - instead of episodes featuring a generic villain of the week in place of Skeletor, Hordak would take the roll. Thundercats did a good job of adding new factions of characters, so having POP and MOTU characters in one cartoon would've worked. MOTU would likely have enjoyed a longer run, since the toy line would receive FULL attention from its primary marketing tool (the cartoon), and the multi media marketing and merchandising would have been consistent in theme. And He-Man's sister would enjoy success in a toy line that wasn't too niche, and appealed to girls that already enjoyed MOTU, and boys that simply wanted to add more characters from the cartoon to their collection.
    Celebrate Princess of Power with Us!
    http://www.facebook.com/messages/103...P/288325415324
    Check out POP videos, reviews and toy checklists.
    http://popclassics.weebly.com

  17. #17
    Council Elder Tallstar's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2001
    Posts
    23,628
    Judging based on what was said in the interviews, it seems like the prototype figure developed via the Boys Department could have simply been used as a jumping-off-point for developing a new figure style, as the objectives were to feminize the body proportions, faces etc. for the Princess of Power line. However, the Crystal Castle prototype with the bird's-beak entrance shown in the U-Matics video definitely *appears* to have originated mostly from the Boys Department. There's an old book from 1990 that references that prototype castle; it was tested with mothers and little girls and apparently they didn't like bird's beak action feature, so Mattel altered it to look like more of a traditional castle.

    Anyhow, if the hands of time were turned back and Mattel kept "whatever her name was" in the Boys Category/MOTU cartoon, I'm not sure that we would have gotten a robust line of female figures or that "She-Ra" would have been iconic or as iconic. You have to consider that there were only 3 female figures made in the 6 years that Mattel was producing MOTU figures (many of which were highly successful years). So, would retail have supported and taken on large line-up of female figures in the boys aisle?

    Sure, girls made up almost 1/3 of the viewership for the Filmation MOTU cartoon, but according to Mattel's Candice Irving the percentage of MOTU toy sales attributed to girls was about 10%. 10% is a good percentage to show potential for growth, but the Girls Department likely didn't think that was enough to convince retailers to do an entire collection in the boys aisle when they were analyzing the market (probably in late 1983, according to my calculations).

  18. #18
    Hexcellent Horror Hostess
    Penny Dreadful's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2002
    Location
    Massachusetts, US
    Posts
    4,554
    Quote Originally Posted by Tallstar View Post
    but according to Mattel's Candice Irving the percentage of MOTU toy sales attributed to girls was about 10%. 10% is a good percentage to show potential for growth, but the Girls Department likely didn't think that was enough to convince retailers to do an entire collection in the boys aisle when they were analyzing the market (probably in late 1983, according to my calculations).
    Hmm, according to Mattel director of marketing Mark Ellis, that number was significantly higher:

    "We were really wrong about the purchases of the line. Girls loved Masters of the Universe and we were blown away when the first purchase study came back and said 30 - 40% of the purchases were for girls. That result set the girls side of Mattel in motion and they developed and launched the She-Ra line. "

    http://www.he-man.org/resources/archive.php?id=1018

    I believe Mark on the percentages since he was in the thick of the vintage MOTU era and would have had direct access to those numbers.

    In his book (as I recall), Roger Sweet says the numbers were actually almost half and half! I don't have the book in front of me so I can't access the exact quote, but he also claimed to have developed something akin to the She-Ra idea early on. I think she may have been He-Man's wife in Sweet's version, but I'd have to double-check the book. I remember he said something about developing a He-Man family or somesuch.

    In any case, I do think the number was quite a bit higher than 10% of girls buying the line, which creates even greater justification for Mattel launching a spin-off line and cartoon.

    I suspect, like with MOTU, it was all a very collaborative process with various people throwing their ideas into the mix. I'm sure BOTH the Boys and Girls departments AND Filmation were all working on something akin to She-Ra. They probably merged a variety of these ideas.


    Incidentally, I remember being quite disappointed that She-Ra and friends weren't PART of the MOTU line back then. After watching SotS, I fully expected those characters to start showing up as part of the line. I guess I wanted everything to be under one umbrella. Luckily, MOTUC has rectified that.
    Last edited by Penny Dreadful; April 2, 2015 at 11:00am.
    PENNY DREADFUL'S SHILLING SHOCKERS
    Hosted horror, sci-fi, suspense, and fantasy films!
    On television scare-waves throughout Haunted New England

    http://www.shillingshockers.com

    TERROR AT COLLINWOOD
    A podcast dedicated to the classic gothic television series, Dark Shadows

    https://www.terroratcollinwood.com/

  19. #19
    Council Elder Tallstar's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2001
    Posts
    23,628
    ^ Here's where I get the 10% from.

    "She-Ra and her associates, who sell for about $6 to $8 each, are not exclusively the domain of girls, said Candace Irving, a Mattel marketing manager. "We have found that girls buy about 10% of the boy-oriented Masters of the Universe toys, and we expect boys will account for a significant percentage of Princess of Power sales, though we don't expect it to reach 10%."
    http://articles.latimes.com/1985-11-...e-patch-kids/2

    Over the years I've seen different percentages quoted for MOTU (girl) toy line sales in various articles etc., and I get the impression that sometimes the viewership percentage for the Filmation MOTU cartoon is mixed up with MOTU toy line sales. The reason I lean toward the 10% figure, is because it's a solid enough of a percentage to be the impetus for creating the separate PoP toy line, but not soooo astronomically high so as to question: "Why the hell didn't the MOTU line have more females?!"

    - - - Updated - - -

    I was going through the files on my computer and I found this second source. (New York Magazine) This one says "between 10 and 15%."


  20. #20
    Heroic Warrior Dayvid's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2013
    Location
    UK
    Posts
    783
    Thanks for this! So interesting!

    Dying to know about these unknown/unproduced characters. Maybe that girl in the bubble carriage was one?

    Ohhh the possibilities! Surely someone will have them somewhere at mattel or not?

  21. #21
    Heroic Warrior mykan's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2009
    Location
    Saint Petersburg, FL
    Posts
    395
    Good stuff with the article, Tallstar. The 10-15% mentioned in the article is not necessarily the final end all be all tally. The 30-40% that Danielle is quoting is possible as a final resulting number. I know in my marketing experience, I have to provide performance numbers within a given promotion period, and often have to revisit those numbers 90 days to even a year later to determine long term growth.

    I'd say that the 30-40% of MOTU sales to girls was the perfect motivator for increasing the number of female characters in the MOTU toy line. These female characters would be included in a "Great Rebellion" sub faction, countering the new Evil Horde sub faction (this mirrors the development plans for the later POG era). As the characters and story developed between Mattel and Filmation for MOTU's Season 3, it's very likely that the GR faction would have been composed of She-Ra, Bow, Glimmer, Angella and Kowl; reflecting the Evil Horde's Hordak, Catra, Leech, Mantenna and Grizzlor (these are the characters that appeared in the origin movie for both factions). This would inject 4 NEW female figures into the line - since they were part of a sub faction, parents and kids would be able to pick and chose which figures were purchased. If the increase in female figs proved successful, more would come in following years...

    Despite plans being worked on in the Boys Dept, the issue here falls to Mattel's #1 PRIORITY - whatever had to be done to increase Barbie $$ would be done. So handing She-Ra over to the Girls Department was an inarguable move. Based on this interview, the most driving aspect of Janice's comments is the flanker brands created for Barbie. These statements give me the impression that the ultimate goal for POP was to create future dollar opportunities for the Barbie, not to create a new female icon. Yes, Janice and her team created the expansive POP line and brand around the She-Ra character, but the She-Ra character was planned for MOTU first as an answer to the Evil Horde and lack of female presence. Whether she had her own show/toy line or not, she would STILL have achieved an iconic status, she was the FEMALE He-Man. The female action figure simply has limited potential - it's too boyish for girls, and too girly for boys. Leaving She-Ra as a more Teela-esque figure would have attracted that 30-40% of girls, and would have been OK for boys to collect. The cartoon would have maintained a focus on MOTU, whilst expanding with new characters, thus keeping the brand fresh and progressive. She-Ra would've gotten more exposure and would have been more accepted - more on par with Teela and Sorceress.
    Celebrate Princess of Power with Us!
    http://www.facebook.com/messages/103...P/288325415324
    Check out POP videos, reviews and toy checklists.
    http://popclassics.weebly.com

  22. #22
    UK MOTU Comics Junkie Mosquitor's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2000
    Location
    Manchester, UK
    Posts
    3,615
    Quote Originally Posted by Penny Dreadful View Post

    In his book (as I recall), Roger Sweet says the numbers were actually almost half and half! I don't have the book in front of me so I can't access the exact quote, but he also claimed to have developed something akin to the She-Ra idea early on. I think she may have been He-Man's wife in Sweet's version, but I'd have to double-check the book. I remember he said something about developing a He-Man family or somesuch.
    Sweet's notes from this stage are in The Power and Honor Foundation vol 1.- The idea was to give He-Man a female counterpart called 'She' and they would have a son called 'He-Boy'. Thankfully this idea got no further than the notes!
    http://www.motuukcomics.co.uk

    The Masters of the Universe/She-Ra UK Comics Fan Site!

  23. #23
    Hexcellent Horror Hostess
    Penny Dreadful's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2002
    Location
    Massachusetts, US
    Posts
    4,554
    Quote Originally Posted by Mosquitor View Post
    Sweet's notes from this stage are in The Power and Honor Foundation vol 1.- The idea was to give He-Man a female counterpart called 'She' and they would have a son called 'He-Boy'. Thankfully this idea got no further than the notes!
    I know right?

    I worked on the Catalog & the guys used Sweet's book, Mastering the Universe: He-Man the Rise and Fall of a Billion Dollar Idea, as one of the reference sources. The part about "She" in particular is on page 128 of Sweet's book - "He-Man can be part of the ultimate super-hero family consisting of his mate 'She,' the ultimate dynamite super-heroine. Amazing in proportions, tremendously powerful, gorgeous & sexy with tan skin and billowing blond hair, making Barbie look wimpy."

    Sweet discusses his perspective on the origins of She-Ra from pgs. 128-130.

    The bit about Jill Barad also comes from Sweet's book. He quotes her remarks from the March 1990 issue of Harper's Bazzar. She claims her sister gave her the idea for She-Ra. Who knows though.

    I was wrong about the "half and half" thing with Sweet. He actually says "girls accounted for a whopping 38% of the sales of all Masters figures," which is very much in line with what Mark Ellis said in his interview. Tallstar's articles deepen the mystery though. Very interesting. Hmm. Mykan's analysis of the percentages might be the answer.
    Last edited by Penny Dreadful; April 3, 2015 at 11:19pm.
    PENNY DREADFUL'S SHILLING SHOCKERS
    Hosted horror, sci-fi, suspense, and fantasy films!
    On television scare-waves throughout Haunted New England

    http://www.shillingshockers.com

    TERROR AT COLLINWOOD
    A podcast dedicated to the classic gothic television series, Dark Shadows

    https://www.terroratcollinwood.com/

  24. #24
    Council Elder Tallstar's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2001
    Posts
    23,628
    Quote Originally Posted by mykan View Post
    Good stuff with the article, Tallstar. The 10-15% mentioned in the article is not necessarily the final end all be all tally. The 30-40% that Danielle is quoting is possible as a final resulting number. I know in my marketing experience, I have to provide performance numbers within a given promotion period, and often have to revisit those numbers 90 days to even a year later to determine long term growth.
    Quote Originally Posted by Penny Dreadful View Post

    I was wrong about the "half and half" thing with Sweet. He actually says "girls accounted for a whopping 38% of the sales of all Masters figures," which is very much in line with what Mark Ellis said in his interview. Tallstar's articles deepen the mystery though. Very interesting. Hmm. Mykan's analysis of the percentages might be the answer.
    It's possible. One thing that is confusing to me though, is the part where Mark Ellis cites the 30 to 40% as being the catalyst for putting the Girls Department on course to create the Princess of Power line. He seems to be referencing sales on the 1982 line-up of MOTU toys (the first year), as it would make sense for the first "Purchase Study" to evaluate 1982 sales, but the version of preliminary design that eventually became known as "New Business Concepts" (the department working on prototype "She-Ra" and Crystal Castle) didn't even exist/wasn't formed until at least around the time of the crash/collapse of Mattel's Intellivison in 1983 and possibly even a little bit later into early 1984.

    Also, in the past, when I've seen a percentage quoted (for "girls sales") in articles, books and so on, often times it's paired up with the approx 1/3 female audience for Filmation MOTU as being another one of the driving factors for putting the Girl's Department into gear on the Princess of Power line. But Filmation MOTU didn't start airing until like September, 1983.

    When I was putting together the interviews on The Star Sisters etc. and finally posted them, I prefaced by saying that some of the information contained could change as new information was discovered etc. This part of Chris McAdam's recollection doesn't appear to be accurate:

    "Originally, Justine proposed the idea of a female superhero named She-Ra as an antithesis to He-Man for the Masters of the Universe product line; because her observation was that the line lacked a female character, and thus this would add an interesting twist."
    Teela already existed before "New Business Concepts" was formed. Ray Wagner, Mattel's president at the time, was responsible for the creation of the new version of the aforementioned department and Susannah Rosenthal was then promoted to VP and headed up NBC. One biography for Susannah states that she was promoted in the "mid-80s".

    Anyhow, it could be that the 30 - 40% is accurate for 1982, but perhaps that number became 10 to 15% in a later year? That's not to say the the female market buying MOTU toys stopped growing/shrank, but maybe the MOTU cartoon had the effect of creating a bigger influx of boys buying the toys, driving down the percentage for the girls. In other words, the percentage of toy sales attributed to girls went down, but the audience was still growing because it was a "smaller percentage of a significantly larger amount of $$$". Or another possibility is that the percentage is for the overall action figure category and not necessarily attributed to MOTU, specifically.

    - - - Updated - - -

    Quote Originally Posted by mykan View Post
    Despite plans being worked on in the Boys Dept, the issue here falls to Mattel's #1 PRIORITY - whatever had to be done to increase Barbie $$ would be done. So handing She-Ra over to the Girls Department was an inarguable move. Based on this interview, the most driving aspect of Janice's comments is the flanker brands created for Barbie. These statements give me the impression that the ultimate goal for POP was to create future dollar opportunities for the Barbie, not to create a new female icon.
    I wouldn't say it was an "inarguable" move. If you will recall, Mattel passed on the opportunity to make Star Wars action figures and then became desperate to come up with something in this boys category that would be on the same level or better. So, that was definitely a priority as well, and a strong argument could have been made for keeping "She-Ra" in MOTU. Moreover, just because Princess of Power was created with the intention of growing the industry, and eventually creating "future dollar opportunities for Barbie", doesn't mean that the people working on the brand weren't invested in doing a good job and hoping to create an icon. A lot was put behind the toy line in an effort to try to make She-Ra iconic. I would say that the "first action figure line for girls" narrative Mattel was trying to create, charity live-action appearances etc., and the fact that She-Ra was headlining her own brand/cartoon significantly contributed to She-Ra's iconic status.
    Last edited by Tallstar; April 4, 2015 at 08:21am.

  25. #25
    Heroic Warrior mykan's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2009
    Location
    Saint Petersburg, FL
    Posts
    395
    Quote Originally Posted by Tallstar View Post
    I wouldn't say it was an "inarguable" move. If you will recall, Mattel passed on the opportunity to make Star Wars action figures and then became desperate to come up with something in this boys category that would be on the same level or better. So, that was definitely a priority as well, and a strong argument could have been made for keeping "She-Ra" in MOTU. Moreover, just because Princess of Power was created with the intention of growing the industry, and eventually creating "future dollar opportunities for Barbie", doesn't mean that the people working on the brand weren't invested in doing a good job and hoping to create an icon. A lot was put behind the toy line in an effort to try to make She-Ra iconic. I would say that the "first action figure line for girls" narrative Mattel was trying to create, charity live-action appearances etc., and the fact that She-Ra was headlining her own brand/cartoon significantly contributed to She-Ra's iconic status.
    I agree. Keep in mind though - the teams that worked on these properties may have worked to make the MOTU and POP iconic, but I'm not sure that Mattel had that as a focus in the long term - Barbie was the flagship, and nothing would stand in the way of that. I suspect that She-Ra benefited more from her cartoon depiction than her toy line. Filmation for example did its best to produce as high a quality series as they could. Mattel just wanted to get 22 minute commercials, whilst Filmation strove to inject as much story and morality into the shows as they could. Mattel wanted as much product shoved into the show, Filmation struggled to not be as blatant in product placement - producers and creators of the shows say as much in the DVD interviews. It's pretty clear Filmation was all for increasing female representation in MOTU, since the cast had two regulars not represented in the toy line (Marlena and Sorceress), and had a plethora of strong female characters written into the story lines on a regular basis - Delora, Hawke, Shokoti, Kittrina, etc. Mattel had been historically resistant to this - even with the Teela character, it was too much to allow for two or even three female characters to exist in the toy line at the time. The creators went back and forth on the female character's role in the line - based on prototype notes, she was an evil sorceress at one point, a goddess at another and a warrior maiden at yet another. These concepts split into two, presumably three, characters - Goddess/Sorceress, Teela and Evil-Lyn. The figure that was finally produced would represent 2 separate characters - at the time one female figure was enough - if you wanted Teela the Warrior, you took off the armor; if you wanted the Goddess, you added the armor.

    The 30% of girls sales in MOTU backed a sentiment that was already strong at Filmation, and also had roots at Mattel. She-Ra looks to have been planned for MOTU (see Lou Scheimer's comments here http://www.awn.com/animationworld/re...w-lou-scheimer) - and the multimedia marketing machine seems to have been well under way by the time she was transferred to Girls. This could account for the disparate concepts we have for POP - one set positions Hordak and the Evil Horde as the villains, and is more of a unisex adventure (based on older MOTU concepts); the other positions Catra as the main antagonist, and is more geared towards girl fantasy (the new Girls Dept POP direction). Further, there are examples of media that are hybrids of the the two, an attempt at trying to align the discrepancies. Disparate concepts were not uncommon with multimedia toy properties, but not this blatantly misaligned - indeed Mattel worked hard to keep MOTU and POP separate, since both toy lines were in separate gendered markets. Because the POP cartoon series was also used to market MOTU, the target audience was girls AND boys. The POP toy line however was clearly marketed towards girls exclusively. I strongly believe this disparate marketing strategy accounts for POP's limited lifespan and success, and also slowed MOTU sales. I'd say the female action figure overall is simply a niche market that just has a perpetually limited scope (I do applaud Mattel's innovation and support of the brand during its life though). In retrospect, the Filmation show, and all media, should have been restructured to better reflect the POP toy line - a consistent message and marketing strategy is crucial to the success of any product. Unfortunately, it seems development was just too far along in too many media areas to go back to the drawing board. Further, She-Ra could've simply remained in the MOTU toy line in the interest of maintaining a targeted marketing focus that would have allowed the brand to whether the storm of steep action figure competition. Girls already liked MOTU the way it was - there was no need to create a Barbie/He-Man hybrid that only a limited target audience would consume.
    Celebrate Princess of Power with Us!
    http://www.facebook.com/messages/103...P/288325415324
    Check out POP videos, reviews and toy checklists.
    http://popclassics.weebly.com

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •